The Indie Game Awards have stripped “Clair Obscur: Expedition 33” of its prizes after Sandfall Interactive admitted to using generative AI in the game’s development – a fact initially undisclosed during the nomination process. This move highlights a growing debate within the indie gaming community about the ethics and transparency surrounding AI-assisted creation.
Initial Submission & Assurance
When submitting “Expedition 33” for consideration, Sandfall Interactive explicitly stated that no generative AI tools were used in the game’s production. This assurance was a condition of eligibility, as the Indie Game Awards maintain strict regulations against AI-generated content. The awards committee relies on developer honesty to ensure fairness and uphold standards for creative integrity.
Disclosure & Disqualification
However, a recent interview with Sandfall Interactive revealed that AI-generated art was indeed integrated into the game’s early stages, though later patched out. This admission triggered an immediate review by the Indie Game Awards, resulting in the disqualification of “Expedition 33” from its nominations.
Why It Matters: The AI Debate
This incident underscores the increasing tension between indie developers and award bodies regarding AI’s role in game creation. Many indie studios rely on AI to streamline workflows, but awards like these often demand full transparency. The key issue is that undisclosed AI usage can be seen as misrepresentation, especially when competing against studios that adhere to stricter, fully human-made production standards.
“While ‘Expedition 33’ remains a quality game, the breach of trust in our nomination process cannot be overlooked. The integrity of the awards hinges on honest submissions.” – Indie Game Awards Statement
The Indie Game Awards’ decision sends a clear message: developers must be forthcoming about their use of AI if they wish to be considered for recognition. This case will likely reshape future submissions and prompt stricter verification processes from other gaming awards.
